State education board hopes to resolve school grades problem by Dec. 4

VERDE VALLEY – Because Arizona’s schools are “so diverse,” the president of the Arizona State Board of Education said Wednesday that it’s “not reasonable” to rate them based on a single accountability system.


"...we evaluate everybodyas fairly as we can.” -Board of Education President Tim Carter

State education board still soliciting public feedback

The Arizona State Board of Education is still accepting public feedback on its A-F Accountability System.

Anyone interested in commenting can either send an email to, fill out a survey which can be found at, or attend any of four open houses which will be held at the Board’s office located at 1700 W. Washington St., Suite 300.

The open houses are scheduled from 9 a.m. until noon Oct. 27, Oct. 30 and Oct. 31; and from noon until 5 p.m. Nov. 6.

“But that’s what the statute requires,” Board of Education President Tim Carter said following the board’s collective Oct. 23 decision to review its new system for grading schools. “And we evaluate everybody as fairly as we can.”

According to Eric Evans, principal at American Heritage Academy in Cottonwood, the board is “doing the right thing” by reevaluating its findings.

“I am not surprised by this move,” said Evans, whose school was given a preliminary D grade. “They had to. They are doing the right thing. The formula/calculations are biased against small, rural schools.”

Had the board issued the preliminary 2016-2017 A-to-F letter grades as final, Carter said “I think it would have been a terrible error.”

On Oct. 9, the Arizona State Board of Education posted the preliminary grades for schools to its website: Initially, the grades were to be preliminary for 90 days, Carter said.

According to Carter, preliminary grades were appealed by about 250 of the close to 1,600 evaluated schools.

“But a lot of schools didn’t receive a grade,” Carter said.

Though not pleased with his school’s preliminary D-letter grade, the principal at American Heritage Academy in Camp Verde Education underwent a “very complicated process.”

Lance Barnes, the principal at American Heritage Academy’s Camp Verde campus said that he does not envy the task of evaluating the state’s schools.


"I’m hoping all the appeals can be resolved.” -Lance Barnes, American Heritage Academy Principal

“The committee met for months and months and pushed back the release date of the evaluation tool several times,” Barnes said. “There were several opportunities for schools to comment. It is a very difficult process to try to evaluate schools that can be very, very difficult using only one measure.”

Carter also said that by the board’s Dec. 4 meeting that issues surrounding the accountability system “would be resolved.”

“I’m hoping all the appeals can be resolved,” Carter said. “In a perfect world. Depends on what the findings are. We may need to continue the process.”

Currently the process involves a board-appointed Technical Advisory Committee – TAC – which has been directed to review the A-F Accountability Plan, business rules and impact data; identify any problematic issues found; and comprehensively report on its findings at the Dec. 4 meeting.

-- Follow Bill Helm on Twitter @BillHelm42


Comments are not posted immediately. Submissions must adhere to our Use of Service Terms of Use agreement. Rambling or nonsensical comments may not be posted. Comment submissions may not exceed a 200 word limit, and in order for us to reasonably manage this feature we may limit excessive comment entries.

britishp 1 year, 2 months ago

I think that school grades aren’t that much of an issue if you look at it from a different angle. The traditional system of assessment has been long ago criticized. Teachers all over the country have been choosing alternative ways to assess their students. The traditional system of education has flaws and errors that’s why the grades aren’t at best these days. I think in order to better the grades students can choose alternative methods of learning and the">StudArea has been helping with this task.